December 22 : 2009
LOTR as the gold standard
New York Times columnist Ross Douthat has written a brief account of the critical reaction to Avatar. He’s surprised to find that there’s a backlash among some of the fanboys that one might expect to love the film, while critics for major news outlets are raving about it. Kind of a reversal of what one might expect. Douthat thinks the professional critics are deliberately brushing aside what he (and many others) perceive as problems with the plot and dialogue, enthusing about the film largely on the basis of its spectacular visuals. He points out that the best effects-heavy films have tights stories and good dialogue–and holds the LOTR trilogy up as one of those that new blockbusters should be measured against.



