July 25 : 2009
Congratulations to John Rateliff!
The Mythopoeic Society has announced its 2009 award winners. In the “Inklings Studies” category, the winner is John Rateliff for his two-volume The History of the Hobbit. It’s a well-deserved win, since the book was a major achievement. As Christopher Tolkien did for The Lord of the Rings in the late volumes of the “History of Middle-earth” series, John includes the major drafts for The Hobbit, along with copious well-informed annotations and essays. I’ve known John for many years, and I can’t imagine anyone better qualified to take on such a project.
(For some reason, only vol. 1 currently seems to be available on Amazon, though you can buy both as part of a boxed set with a copy of The Hobbit. I happen to have about half a dozen copies of The Hobbit, so I just bought the two volumes. If Amazon doesn’t rectify its mistake soon–yes, they actually do make mistakes–I’m sure you can track it down elsewhere.)
John wasn’t at the society’s banquet to accept the award, but he has posted an acceptance speech anyway, on his blog. It’s good to hear that he will have even more to say on the subject:
After he plowed through The History of The Hobbit, Charles Noad wrote “surely nothing remains to be said.” Happily he was wrong. Trying to get to the bottom of a Tolkien story is like staring into an ent’s eyes: deep wells very much in the present but filled with the memory of ages. But who wouldn’t drink deep of that well, given the chance? So: the work goes on.
There’s no significant film connection in these books. Still, John is a big fan of Peter Jackson’s trilogy and has been a defender of it among the those people in the world of Tolkien scholarship who deplore the adaptations.
I also know that he reads this blog, so congratulations, John!



