MSNBC’s website has just reported on two rulings that were given yesterday in the Tolkien Trust’s lawsuit against New Line Cinema over money allegedly owed from the LOTR film trilogy revenues.
One ruling by Judge Ann I. Jones sets a March 3 deadline for both sides to exchange documents. According to the report, “The papers will be reviewed by both sides in preparation for their appearance before a mediator in mid-March or April to try and settle the case.”
The Trust also was given the right to “wait until an expert they hire has finished documenting their claims for a 7.5 [percent] royalty from the [sic] ‘The Two Towers’ film before presenting that information to New Line.”
Another passage reads, “Lawyers for the trust are seeking hundreds of thousands of documents and say they have received less than half of what they need.” Apparently New Line plans to turn over most of what remains by the end of this month. The studio’s lawyer claims that the defense has turned over 60 percent of requested documents so far. “But he said some of the documents are harder to find than others.”
This exchange of documents is part of the “discovery” phase, where both sides gather evidence, often requested from the opposing side, to bolster their cases.
The case has seen some other developments over the past few months, and once I get a look at these new rulings, I plan to post another of my long summaries of what has been happening.
In the meantime, this is the first I have heard that there may be a meeting of the two parties before a mediator within the next two months or so. If the case can be settled in that way, we won’t have to wait until the October 19 trial date–which could always be delayed. If some major piece of evidence has turned up, it might make one side or the other more interested in a settlement.
(Thanks to TheOneRing.net for posting this link!)